Toby Carvery vs Miller and Carter: Which Is Best for You?
Toby Carvery vs Miller and Carter: Which Should You Book?
Toby Carvery vs Miller and Carter is a choice many diners face when planning a meal out: a hearty carvery for a modest price, or a steakhouse dinner that costs quite a bit more. Both brands are owned by Mitchells & Butlers, the same pub and restaurant group, yet they aim at very different evenings. The short answer is this: pick Toby Carvery for a family roast dinner that keeps the bill low, and pick Miller and Carter when the steak itself is the point of the night.
The rest of this guide breaks down how the two compare on food, price, atmosphere, family appeal and booking, so you can match the restaurant to your plans.
Toby Carvery vs Miller and Carter at a glance
Use this table for a quick side by side view before reading the detail.
| Detail | Toby Carvery | Miller and Carter |
|---|---|---|
| Concept | Carvery deck with a minimum of three roasted meats carved at the counter, plus help yourself vegetables and trimmings | Steakhouse with British and Irish beef matured for a minimum of 30 days, grilled to order and served with accompaniments |
| Typical main course | £11.49 to £15.79 for a carvery plate, depending on the day | Steaks reported at around £26 to £45 for 30 day matured cuts |
| Deals and set menus | Weekday set menu with two courses at £12.99 and three courses at £14.99, meat free carvery £1.75 less than the meat carvery | Weekday lunch set menu reported from £19.95 for two courses; seasonal set menus and voucher deals appear through the year |
| Drinks | Pub drinks at pub prices, full bar with draught beers and soft drinks | Full bar with a longer wine list aimed at steak pairing, plus cocktails |
| Booking | Walk ins welcome; booking advised at busy times, especially Sundays | Booking recommended, especially Friday and Saturday evenings and festive periods |
| Who it suits | Families, big groups, anyone who wants a filling roast dinner without a big bill | Couples, steak lovers, business dinners and special occasions |
Food and concept
The two brands could hardly work differently. At Toby Carvery you queue at the carvery deck, choose from the roasted meats on offer that day, and watch them carved onto your plate. The usual line up includes roast turkey, roast beef, roast gammon and roast pork, with lamb typically joining on Saturdays and Sundays. You then help yourself to unlimited freshly steamed and roasted vegetables, Yorkshire puddings, mac and cheese, and ruffled roasties cooked in beef dripping or plain, along with stuffing and gravy. You can go back for more vegetables as many times as you like.
Miller and Carter works like a traditional steakhouse. Steaks are the core of the menu, cut from British and Irish beef that is matured for a minimum of 30 days, and cooked to the doneness you ask for. The range runs from rump and sirloin through ribeye, fillet and a 20oz T bone, with Tomahawk sharing cuts for bigger appetites. If you want to compare the main options, see our Miller and Carter menu guide and our ranking of the best cuts of beef to decide which cut suits you.
Neither menu is steaks only. Toby Carvery serves starters, sandwiches, vegetarian and vegan dishes such as the meat free carvery, and breakfast, including a full English. Miller and Carter also serves breakfast at many sites, as covered in our Miller and Carter breakfast guide, plus burgers, fish and vegetarian mains. But at Miller and Carter the steak is clearly the headline act, while at Toby the roast dinner is the whole point.
Price and value
This is the biggest practical difference. Toby Carvery is built around low prices for generous plates. The official menu shows the carvery at £11.49 Monday to Friday, £13.29 on Saturday, and £15.79 on Sundays and bank holidays, with a meat free carvery £1.75 cheaper than the meat version. There is also a weekday set menu with two courses at £12.99 and three courses at £14.99. Kingsize upgrades, which add extra meat, an extra Yorkshire pudding and two chipolatas, cost extra. Last checked: 13 October 2026.
Miller and Carter sits roughly two to three times higher for a comparable meal. Steaks are reported at around £26 for a 9oz rump rising to around £45 for the 20oz T bone, with 50 day matured and Wagyu cuts above that. These are reported prices from third party menu sites rather than the official menu, so treat them as a guide. A weekday lunch set menu is reported from £19.95 for two courses. See our Miller and Carter lunch menu page for the best value ways to eat there. Last checked: 13 October 2026.
Value depends on what you want from the evening. Toby wins on pure value for money: a filling two course meal for under £15 is hard to argue with. Miller and Carter wins if you judge value by the quality of the steak on the plate, since 30 day matured beef costs the kitchen a lot more than carvery joints.
Atmosphere and occasion
Toby Carvery restaurants are relaxed pub restaurants. The feel is casual and family friendly, with room for prams, big tables and noisy Sunday lunches. It is the kind of place where you can take grandparents and toddlers at the same table without worrying about the formality of it all.
Miller and Carter restaurants are darker and more polished, with leather seating and a quieter dining room. The atmosphere is closer to a restaurant for a night out than a pub lunch. That makes it a natural fit for date nights, anniversary dinners and business meals where the setting matters as much as the food.
Both get busy at peak times. Toby is at its busiest on Sunday lunchtimes, when the queue at the carvery deck can be long. Miller and Carter fills up on Friday and Saturday evenings, so book ahead if you want a prime time table.
Families and groups
Toby Carvery is the stronger pick for families with young children. The format suits fussy eaters because everyone builds their own plate, the prices keep a family meal affordable, and the relaxed setting means nobody minds a bit of noise. Larger groups are easy to accommodate at the big tables, and booking ahead is wise on Sundays.
Miller and Carter welcomes families too and has a kids menu, but it is designed more for adults. Children who like steak will be happy; children who want to pile their own plate may prefer Toby. For big celebrations at Miller and Carter, festive menus such as the Christmas Day menu and the Mothers Day menu are worth checking, and the Boxing Day menu covers the days around Christmas.
If your group is really watching the budget, our Bar and Block steakhouse menu and Beefeater menu and locations guides cover two more Mitchells & Butlers grill brands that sit between the two on price.
Booking and locations
Toby Carvery has by far the larger estate, with around 150 restaurants across England, Wales and Scotland, so most diners have one within easy reach. Miller and Carter has a smaller estate that continues to grow. Interestingly, several Miller and Carter restaurants opened in buildings that used to be Toby Carvery sites, including Grimsby, Bury and Swansea, which tells you how the group sees the two brands fitting together.
Both accept bookings, and both are sensible to book at peak times. For Toby, that means Sunday lunch and bank holidays. For Miller and Carter, Friday and Saturday evenings and occasions like Valentines Day and Christmas. For big groups, phone the restaurant directly to confirm they can seat everyone together.
What each does better than the other
What Toby Carvery does better
Toby Carvery wins on value, choice for mixed groups and the sheer comfort of a proper roast dinner. The unlimited vegetables mean big appetites leave full without paying more, and the low prices make it the easy choice when you are feeding a family or a group on a budget. It is also the better option if not everyone wants the same thing, since the deck suits meat lovers, vegetarians and fussy eaters alike.
What Miller and Carter does better
Miller and Carter wins on the steak itself. Thirty day matured cuts, cooked to order, in cuts like the T bone steak are a different proposition from carvery beef. The drinks list, with wines chosen for steak and a cocktail list, suits a proper night out. And the calmer, smarter dining room makes it the better setting for occasions when the meal matters.
The verdict: which should you book
There is no single winner, only the right choice for the evening you have planned.
- Date night or anniversary: Miller and Carter. Better setting, better steak, better drinks.
- Family Sunday roast on a budget: Toby Carvery. Filling plates, low prices, and everyone eats what they like.
- Weekday dinner without spending much: Toby Carvery, or the Miller and Carter lunch set menu if you want steak at a lower price.
- Business dinner: Miller and Carter. Quieter room and a menu that suits an expense account better than a carvery queue.
- Feeding a crowd of mixed ages: Toby Carvery for ease, though check Miller and Carter festive menus if the occasion calls for something more special.
Frequently asked questions
Is Toby Carvery cheaper than Miller and Carter?
Yes, by a clear margin. A Toby carvery costs £11.49 to £15.79 depending on the day, while a Miller and Carter steak alone is reported at around £26 to £45. Expect to pay roughly two to three times more per head at Miller and Carter.
Are Toby Carvery and Miller and Carter owned by the same company?
Yes. Both brands are owned and operated by Mitchells & Butlers, the Birmingham based pub and restaurant group.
Which is better for kids, Toby Carvery or Miller and Carter?
Toby Carvery suits most families better: children build their own plates, prices stay low, and the relaxed setting works for all ages. Miller and Carter has a kids menu, but the atmosphere and prices are aimed at adults.
Do I need to book at Miller and Carter?
It is strongly recommended, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings and around festive dates. Toby Carvery accepts walk ins but booking ahead is wise for Sunday lunch and bank holidays.
The Grill Guide is an independent information website. Menus, prices and offers vary by restaurant and change over time, so please confirm current details with the restaurant before ordering or booking.
